Clusters and benchmarks on the dynamics of nanoscience and nanotechnology
  • Français
  • English
Main menu
Home
Contact us
Site map
Search
Tag cloud
Researches
Nanotechnology
Research and industry
Corner of maps
Resources
Glossaries
Bibliography
Reading logs
Info nano
Web links
 
 
Fuzzy old world: A response to Markusen

Book or journal references : Regional Studies, vol. 37, pp. 729-740 (2003).

Author(s) : Peck , J.

Abstract :

Critical regional studies and economic geography have both taken 'qualitative turns' over the past 15 years. The paper takes issue with the claim that this methodological shift has entailed declining standards of evidence, a proclivity for 'fuzzy' theorizing, and a drift into policy irrelevance, making instead a positive argument for the further deepening of intensive, case-study approaches. This need not occur at the expense of quantitative research, because there is not a zero-sum competition in research methods. There should be continuing methodological pluralism, and intensive methods have a legitimate and important role to play. In this spirit, an argument is made for extending case-study methodologies in critical regional studies. The field needs more, not less, of this kind of work. There is no reason to believe that it will be any less rigorous or relevant as a result.


Keywords :

research methods; economic geography; critical regional studies ECONOMIC-GEOGRAPHY; LOCAL GOVERNANCE; ORGANIZATION; INTERVIEW; POLITICS; MARKET; RIGOUR; GAMES; LABOR

©2006 - 2010 Clusters and benchmarks on the dynamics of nanoscience and nanotechnology